In Caracas
12/08/2004
- Opinión
It has been an interesting night and day. I have spent a substantial
portion of the past 24 hours listening to Chavez speak. The man speaks a
lot. But let me explain.
Fear...
My interest in Venezuela started with my interest and work on Colombia.
It seemed to me like the two countries, linked historically in so many
ways, were living completely different histories today. I remember the
coup in April 2002 in Venezuela and a moment when I thought Venezuela was
going to go that same route-of paramilitarism, of neoliberalism based on
massacre and assassination. But over the past two years Venezuelans have
beaten repeated attempts at plunging them into that kind of future.
But yesterday I learned that I had overlooked something else-that that
history of murderous counterinsurgency is very much a part of Venezuela´s
own history. Last night, at the Complejo Cultural Teatro Teresa Carreno
(which is a theatre built for the rich for their own use), there was a
really moving event. An auditorium of well over a thousand people, mostly
young people, students-real people, not elites-came to a launch of the
fourth edition of a book by a journalist who is now the Vice President of
Venezuela, Jose Vicente Rangel. The book, ´Expediente Negra´, is an
investigation of human rights violations committed during the years of
"democracy" here in Venezuela. There was a guerrilla insurgency here, in
the 1960s and 1970s, and it, like so much else, was repressed savagely-the
whole gambit of disappearances, massacres, assassinations. One President
held publicly to the dictum of "shoot first, find out later".
In addition to the strangeness of an elite theatre filled with people, the
event itself was quite dignified, I thought. It would have been easy to
do wrong: to turn an event that was a kind of commemoration into a way of
scoring political points. But-and this is not to deny that political
points were scored-the dead were honoured. Several family members of the
disappeared spoke, and told their stories. There were cultural events,
musical groups in between the speeches. And yes, there was Chavez, on the
screen and in person.
The theme of the evening was "recovering memory" ("recuperar" in spanish
has a deeper meaning than recovery in english). The disappeared were
shown on screen. Their families held up their pictures. Their names were
named (Alberto Lovera, Alejandro Tejero, Andres y Jose Ramon Pasquier,
Jose Carmelo Mendoza, Luis Alberto Hernandez... and on and on). A famous
musician of the era, Ali Primera, has a song, based on something a famous
priest said during a service for one of the dead decades ago-"Those who
die for life, cannot be called dead" (again, something is lost in the
translation but you get the idea). The photos were shown in a montage, to
the music of Ali Primera.
What was the political point of all this? Well, at the beginning of this
note I said that my initial interest in Venezuela was not that of someone
looking for the authentic revolution or the next revolutionary fashion-it
was, instead, a kind of fear of a situation that was close to the brink,
with paramilitaries sharpening their knives and waiting for their chance
to restore neoliberalism. I thought of Colombia-but Venezuelans have
their own, living memories of all this. And it only made sense for
Chavez's people to want to remind Venezuelans of what came before. Chavez
does not do disappearances, torture, and massacres, though they accuse him
of being a dictator. Venezuelans know this. And many of the people in
the opposition are people who did participate in all this. So the cry,
"no volveran!" (they will not return!)
Chavez talks...
The evening ended with a lot of Chavez. First, Luis Britto, one of the
old generation of leftists who is part of the government, showed some
interesting videos. To those who accuse us of censorship, he said, let me
remind you of this freedom of press. He then showed two videos of the
current vice president, Jose Vicente Rangel, who was in the 1990s a TV
personality, trying to interview Chavez, who was in jail after trying to
overthrow the regime in a coup in 1992. Both times, the interviews were
censored, in a very crude way-a big red "CENSURADO" sign was pasted on
Chavez´s face and the attempt ended.
But then, Britto showed a video of a very long interview Rangel did with
Chavez two days before Chavez won the elections of 1998. That was an
interesting interview-good questions, good answers. Rangel asked about
power-they say you are a man who wants power, Chavez... why? Power for
what? Chavez said, power isn't like a glass of water you pick up-it is
something you build... I want to build a new kind of power, democratic
power, popular power.
After the long interview, Chavez got up to speak himself. "I will be
brief", he began, and he was-he only talked for an hour. He told a story
of when he was in the army, and how he witnessed the torture of two
campesinos where he was posted as a young sub-lieutenant in the 1970s. He
tried, and failed, to stop it, but decided then that he had to do
something. There were more stories, too, all trying to return to the
point that all those who died fighting for change did not die in vain,
that today´s process is built on their sacrifices.
And talks some more...
Then, this morning, I did what any good journalist should do once in a
lifetime-I went to a mainstream press conference at the Presidential
palace! Now that was a genuine media circus. Several hundred people,
from mainstream media all over Latin America, Europe, and some of our
friends from the United States as well. Indeed, Venezuela´s good friend
Juan Forero (read his NYT reports on Colombia and Venezuela if you have a
strong stomach) was sitting just a couple of seats from me. I got to
watch him school another American journalist about all the money that
Chavez is spending on frivolous things like education, health care, and
Argentine beef. I got to watch him elbow that same American journalist
and chuckle when Chavez mentioned how infallible the new voting system and
voting machines were (that gave me a bit of the chills, actually,
especially after getting a chance to read Greg Palast´s latest... do they
know something we don´t? All sides here seem to like the machines. Is
that not a sure sign som The American journalists (you can probably read
more about this on Narconews-there was a solid Narconews team there today)
projected this air of world-weariness, cynicism, and wisdom to the ways of
overblown politicians. That attitude was striking, considering how little
wisdom or doubt they exhibit when dealing with their own government. But
not, perhaps, surprising.
At any rate, Chavez hit his usual notes in the press conference: Latin
American integration, opposition to neoliberalism, the likely overwhelming
victory in the referendum, the readiness and preparation for any
'irregularities', the long history of US destabilization (mentioning Chile
many times) in the region.
My two favourite quotes from the press conference were the following.
First, when asked about what he hopes for from the US, he said-"we could
hope for a lot. What couldn´t we accomplish with the US on our side?
What couldn´t we accomplish in fighting poverty, fighting for education,
for health care, for literacy in the neighbourhoods? What couldn't we
accomplish for all of the Americas, or for the whole world? I would be
the first one to ally with the United States for something like that. But
we cannot hope for anything like that. I read this morning that the US is
about to take Najaf. Instead of withdrawing from Iraq, as Spain did, in a
very dignified way, as other Latin American countries did, they are making
this terrible mistake, with its terrible consequences, even worse." He
reminded the audience that Venezuela always opposed and continues to
oppose the war in Iraq. And he reminded those present that the reason the
price of oil is climbing is because of that war, in part.
My other favourite quote was about the CIA itself. When asked about the
CIA, he said: "You know, it is like James Bond. Now, I love James Bond.
I think the Sean Connery James Bond movies are irreplaceable. But James
Bond is not as cool now as he was." (this is fairly loose translation,
forgive me) "Look at Dracula! Is the new Dracula as scary as Bela
Lugosi´s Dracula? Superman? Even Batman, he's not scary any more, and
neither is Robin! The same is true of the CIA. We, a third world,
underdeveloped country, we have taped the CIA giving classes here in
Venezuela-that is, we have infiltrated them. I've called the US Embassy
to ask them to stop trying to infiltrate our military-I know the military,
when something is going on, they tell me..." When asked if the US would
try to destabilize Venezuela, he said they probably would. "But they will
fail, again and again."
Let´s make a deal?
On the streets tonight, there are demonstrations. One of the opposition,
the 'Si' camp, which by the private TV networks looks like it has hundreds
of thousands (check out venezuelanalysis.com for last Sunday's 'No' march
photos). And another, a street party at the palace, of the 'No'. You
see, there is no campaigning allowed on Friday and Saturday-so this is the
last night to publicly campaign (we will see how this rule is bent or
broken tomorrow...) I am in the wrong place, writing when I should be on
the street. But, I should mention the one thing that the mainstream media
are likely to pick up about Chavez's speech today.
There was a tone of wanting to play ball: Chavez mentioned the pipeline
deal with Uribe. He quoted from many mainstream Wall Street journalists
and analysts who predicted chaos, and who predicted that a Chavez victory
would bring stability to the markets which the markets, especially the oil
markets, need right now, whereas the opposition has no plan and no idea
how to govern the country. In the midst of some very solid talk about
Latin American integration, the irreversible changes to the constitution
and in terms of land reform, housing, education, health, that have been
mobilizing and democratizing forces, there was also this sense, that the
government could work with the multinationals, work on the megaprojects,
and cooperate in some areas. I imagine the mainstream media will seize on
this.
The next days of non-campaigning promise to be interesting. Maybe a
chance to get out of the media zone and talk to some people...
This message has been brought to you by ZNet (http://www.zmag.org). Visit
our site for subscription options.
https://www.alainet.org/en/active/6586
Del mismo autor
- The police system that terrorizes the poor and minorities is rooted in the colonial past 23/10/2020
- Colombia's magic laptops and the war against social movements 06/03/2009
- Los más recientes prisioneros políticos 16/04/2008
- Basta de rumores devastadores 14/03/2006
- Stop the Deadly Rumours 23/02/2006
- In Caracas 12/08/2004
- La lucha por Colombia 14/03/2004