The Brazil risk
25/06/2002
- Opinión
People talk about "the Brazil risk" as if this country were not already
foundering in alarming social indices. The risk is to stay on the same
course, deepening even more the social inequality and the exclusion of a
majority of the population. We're not the ones who tomorrow should fear the
Argentina of today. It's the neighboring nation that fears to be tomorrow
the Brazil of today. Just remember that the population of Argentina (about
36 million) is smaller than the number of Brazilians who live below the
poverty line. The two nations no longer put up with leaders who are
indifferent to the social sphere. Over there, bank depositors cannot
withdraw their savings. Here, the Central Bank reduced the yield of funds.
Over there, people take to the streets. Here, they prepare to go to the
polls.
Brazil is the world's 10th-ranking economy. Therefore, it's a rich nation,
out of step with all the others because it's saddled with a very high index
of poverty. Within the Brazilian population, how many live in abject
poverty? The World Bank says 15 million; the Institute for the Research of
Applied Economics (IPEA), 22 million; the Citizenship Institute, 44
million; and the Getúlio Vargas Foundation, 50 million. Statistics aside,
you need only open a window to see the pitiful scenes below the bridges.
Above the poverty line, 30 million more people make do on a monthly income
of less than 80 reales. Altogether, 53 million Brazilians live below the
poverty line. That contradiction is due to the economic model adopted by
the federal government in the past eight years, which stresses the
concentration of income. Twenty-one percent of the Gross Domestic Product
(about 1 billion reales at present) is set aside for the social sector. No
other Latin American nation, with the exception of Cuba, spends so much on
social issues - 6 reales out of every 10 reales collected. It so happens
that the poor get the least amount of that money. Almost half of the money
paid to retirees goes to the richest people, who account for 10 percent of
the population. Only 7 percent goes to the poorest, who account for 20
percent of the population. The public universities (which educate the élite
of Brazil) swallow about 60 percent of the budget for education. And only 2
percent of the social area is set aside, for example, for basic sanitation,
which is indispensable to reduce infant mortality and the spread of
infectious diseases, such as yellow fever and Chagas disease. As Oded
Grajew puts it, what's the use of mopping the floor when the roof is
leaking.
One of the indices to measure indigence is used by the World Health
Organization, which deems as impoverished anyone without enough resources
to consume 2,000 calories per day, an amount indispensable for a productive
person. This implies the daily consumption of 1½ rolls of bread, some
margarine, five spoonsful of rice, half a spoonful of beans, a glass of
milk, a 100-gram slice of beef, half an egg, three spoonsful of sugar, soy
oil, and flours made from wheat and yucca. That's very little. In fact,
it's nothing in a country that has more than enough food. Why, this year's
grain harvest is sure to exceed 99 million tons! As Amartya Sen, Nobel
laureate in economics, observes, there are nations where destitution is
measured by the lack of foodstuffs and there are others where it's measured
by the lack of money in the pockets of the people, which is our case. The
distribution of income and agrarian reform are two challenges that no
government has surmounted in the history of Brazil.
Trying to document the indigence of Brazilians is enough to drive one to
indignation. Still, something even more worrisome looms ahead: According to
the Getúlio Vargas Foundation, almost one half of the destitute (45
percent) are children and adolescents not yet 15 years old. Seventeen
percent of the destitute are youngsters 16 to 25 years old. What future
awaits those who escape an early death?
As Fernando Henrique Cardoso himself conceded, we are an unfair nation. Of
the 830 million poorest people in the world, 3 percent live in our country.
That wouldn't be too bad if our foreign trade didn't represent less than 1
percent of the trade movement worldwide. Just to give you an idea:
Switzerland's foreign trade in 1990 accounted for 6 percent of the world
trade. According to the IPEA, the gap between the richest 20 percent and
the poorest 20 percent of the population is five-fold; in the United
States, eight-fold; in Mexico, 13-fold; in Chile, 18-fold; in Brazil, 33-
fold.
It is a proven fact that the higher the parents' level of education, the
greater the educational achievement of their children. To invest in
elementary education would be one way to disarm the mechanisms of income
concentration in Brazil, where 1 percent of the population has the same
amount of resources as the poorest 50 percent! In addition to the lack of
an effective agrarian reform, the lack of an effective housing reform
affects 12 percent of the population (20.2 million people). According to
the João Pinheiro Foundation, Brazil has 44.9 million homes. It needs 6.6
million more.
The Brazil risk will continue to grow, unless the nation this year decides
to remove from the electoral map those politicians who have no programs to
reduce indigence and social exclusion. By the way, the National Conference
of Bishops of Brazil (CNBB, the acronym in Portuguese) is staging a
national mutirão (collective action by the community) against indigence and
hunger. In the case of Brazil, it's not a question of multiplying the
loaves. It's simply a question of handing them out.
* Frei Betto co-authored, with Emir Sader, the book "Contraversões -
civilização y barbárie na virada do século" (Boitempo Publ.), and other
books.
(Translation in to English: Progreso Semanal y Progreso Weekly)
https://www.alainet.org/es/node/106014?language=es
Del mismo autor
- Homenaje a Paulo Freire en el centenario de su nacimiento 14/09/2021
- Homenagem a Paulo Freire em seu centenário de nascimento 08/09/2021
- FSM: de espaço aberto a espaço de acção 04/08/2020
- WSF: from an open space to a space for action 04/08/2020
- FSM : d'un espace ouvert à un espace d'action 04/08/2020
- FSM: de espacio abierto a espacio de acción 04/08/2020
- Ética em tempos de pandemia 27/07/2020
- Carta a amigos y amigas del exterior 20/07/2020
- Carta aos amigos e amigas do exterior 20/07/2020
- Direito à alimentação saudável 09/07/2020