Incoming Brazilian President Adept at Check Mating Bush
13/12/2002
- Opinión
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva, the incoming president of Brazil, is
demonstrating an uncanny ability to move forward a progressive
agenda while keeping his conservative antagonists at bay. This
was clearly demonstrated in his meeting with George W. Bush in
Washington on December 10. Pablo Gentili, an Argentine
international analyst at the State University of Rio de Janeiro
declares: "Da Silva reaped the support of the Bush administration
while making it clear that his government will set its own agenda
and priorities. He has an extraordinary capacity to build broad
support for his left-leaning policies in the face of domestic and
international adversity."
Before da Silva's arrival in Washington key Republican
Congressional figures, along with right wing conservatives
identified with the Reagan administration's bellicose policies in
Central America, were calling for Bush to take a tough stand
against the incoming president who is common referred to as
"Lula." They decried the new leftist threat in Latin America,
asserting a "Lula, Castro, Chavez axis" was in the making,
referring to Presidents Fidel Castro of Cuba and Hugo Chavez of
Venezuela.
Lula had also been hit by international speculators prior to his
visit to Washington. Fearful that the social policies advocated by
the new government will adversely affect Brazil's ability to make
payments of its huge international debt totaling $240 billion, the
investment bank of J P Morgan on December 2 down graded its
rating of Brazil from "neutral" to "negative." This shift led to a
slide in the value of Brazil's currency, the Real, and a slump in
the country's stock market.
As Francisco Meneses of IBASE, an independent research
institute in Rio de Janeiro, notes, "Lula before coming to
Washington positioned himself so that international institutions
and politicians like Bush would find it difficult to go after him."
The day after he won the Brazilian election Lula declared that his
number one priority when he takes office on January 1 is to end
hunger among 23 million Brazilians, approximately one-seventh
of the country's population. The campaign will be accompanied
by increased subsidies to poor families aimed at keeping their
children in school, by a fairly radical agrarian reform program,
and by significant government support for agricultural
cooperatives.
"By making the ending of hunger his number one priority, Lula
has inoculated himself against many of his detractors," says
Meneses. As an expert on agrarian issues, Meneses has been
participating in the planning meetings for the government's
campaign against hunger. He says the World Bank along with the
United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization have already
informally committed their institutions to spending $5 billion
over the next four years on the campaign against hunger.
Even the most orthodox international lending institutions have
been check mated by da Silva's announced policies. Just days before Lula
left for Washington, the head of the International Monetary Fund, Horst
Kohler, went to Brazil. After meeting with Lula, Kohler
proclaimed that the incoming president "is a leader for the
twenty-first century." He even endorsed Lula's call for increased
social spending and lamented J.P. Morgan's downgrading of
Brazil's investment rating.
One major area of discussion between the Bush administration
and Lula in Washington focused on the Free Trade Area of the
Americas (FTAA). Bush has made this agreement the lynchpin of
his Latin American policy, calling for all the countries of the
hemisphere (excepting Cuba) to begin reducing trade barriers in
2005. Lula has repeatedly expressed reservations about FTAA,
asserting that it favors US domination of Latin America.
Lula positioned himself strategically in the FTAA debate by
meeting with regional allies before going to Washington. As
Marcos Arruda, a foreign policy consultant to the incoming
government notes, "Lula intentionally visited neighboring
countries before visiting Bush to make it clear he would not
grovel for US support and that Brazil has its own agenda and
interests in South America.' On December 2 Lula visited
Argentina, Brazil's leading partner in MercoSur, the regional
trade block that also includes Uruguay and Paraguay. Next he
went to Chile, an associate member of MercoSur. In his major
address in Buenos Aires Lula called for a strengthening of
MercoSur "so we can take control our destiny" and end "our
dependency on international currency flows." Lula, in Argentina
as well as Chile, asserted that MercoSur should take priority over
other trade agreements, and went on to call for a common
currency among MercoSur nations and the formation of a regional
Parliament.
In Washington Lula was able to seize the commercial high ground
by pointing to a series of US protectionist measures that actually
run counter to authentic free trade. Approximately 25% of
Brazil's exports valued at over $14 billions currently go to the
United States. Twenty of the leading products face average US
tariffs of 39%. If the trade barriers were removed on just four
products—orange juice, steel, meat and soy products--it is
estimated that annual Brazilian exports to the US would jump by
$2 billion.
Francisco Meneses of IBASE believes it is doubtful that the talks
between Lula and Bush will actually lead to any significant
reduction of U.S. trade barriers, particularly on products like
orange juice. "Bush's brother Jeb as governor of Florida
obviously has a stake in keeping out Brazilian juice because of his
alliance with local orange growers." Moreover, Meneses worries
that even the apparently favorable rapport between Lula and
George W. Bush will soon sour. "With Iraq and the Middle East
the administration has its hands full, it doesn't want to create a
crisis with the Lula government for now. Bush is biding his time.
He will wait for the inevitably deeper reactions of domestic and
international interests opposed to Lula's progressive social
policies before moving against the new government."
-----
Roger Burbach is director of the Center for the Study of the
Americas. He co-edited with Ben Clarke the anthology:
September 11 and the US War: Beyond the Curtain of Smoke,
City Lights Books, 2002.
https://www.alainet.org/es/node/109148?language=en
Del mismo autor
- The US and the Confrontation in Venezuela 24/02/2014
- Elections in Venezuela and Chile Advance Left Agenda and Latin American Economic Integration 06/01/2014
- Meet General Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, General Augusto Pinochet's Heir Apparent in Egypt 26/08/2013
- Open Letter to Edward Snowden 14/07/2013
- Chavez Renewed Latin America and Revived Socialism 07/03/2013
- Cuba, a Society in Motion 26/06/2012
- The global revolt and Latin America 09/01/2012
- The global revolt of 2011 – a turning point in history 21/11/2011
- Chilean student movement leads uprising for transformation of the country 12/08/2011
- Communitarian Socialism 05/04/2010