the ethical rebellion
01/11/2000
- Opinión
The Workers' Party (PT), won in the elections for 187 mayors and 2,485
city councilors throughout Brazil. This is not just a victory. It is,
above all, a responsibility. The results confirmed the positive
valuation, on the part of the voters, of the PT way of governing, which
was established in municipalities like Porto Alegre, Ribeirao Preto,
and Santo Andre.
It was an ethical rebellion of the voters. The immunity and impunity
of so many corrupt politicians, added to the misappropriation of public
funds, pushed part of the electorate to demonstrate its disapproval of
the politicians. The deception grew with the government of Fernando
Henrique Cardoso. Not even the opposition expected that, in the
Presidency, the sociologist would take a knife in hand to relentlessly
slash the social budget.
Aquiles, after all, did not lose his heel because he had an
invulnerable body. The new administrations need to do justice to the
ethical rebellion, avoiding the slightest indication of nepotism,
favoritism, or under-the-table agreements.
One sensitive point of Brazilian politics which demands to be attacked
by the PT: campaign funding. Many politicians and policies are hostage
to banks, businesses, and contractors. Even in the PT the Robin Hood
syndrome has limits. In general the financiers take the best, which
subjects democracy to economic power. Electoral legislation needs to
be reformed in order to assure that the campaign's fairness is
controlled and transparent.
If in the next two years, the new administrations do not demonstrate
coherency in fulfilling their promises, they will give their
adversaries the triumph of an incompetence capable of assuring the
continuance of this mistaken economic policy, which benefits the
international creditors and promotes internal exclusion. Only the
endeavor to achieve tax reform can reverse the aberration of this
model, which concentrates income in the hands of the federal government
and decentralizes services to the municipalities.
New mayors mean a new governing team, above all in vital functions. It
could be ingenuous to retain in positions of trust those who do not
feel a kinship with the new project. In this sense, the tradition of
the Dominican Order has been an example of democracy for 800 years:
when the mandate of a superior ends, everyone who was appointed by him
is peremptorily dismissed.
The best criticism of the neoliberal policy adopted by the federal
government - via irresponsible privatizations that now penalize the
population, such as telecommunications - is to offer efficient
services. Good intentions don't mean much if the town council is
incapable of improving the performance and quality of health and
sanitation services, of fixing potholes in the streets, or assuring
places in school and transport for those without.
It is not enough for the media to function as ombudsmen for the
municipal government. Generally, whoever is in power only has ears for
praise, and any criticism sounds like an opposition plot. It would be
a good idea to have a team of ombudsmen, from political analysts to
popular leaders, to open the eyes and pierce the ears of anyone who
runs the risk of turning politics into a narcissistic game.
The PT introduced innovations into public administration by
implementing programs like the participatory budget, school
scholarships, the people's bank, family doctors, minimum income, etc.
But it runs the risk of paternalism or exclusion towards popular
movements, turning them into transmission belts, or empty shells. A
project born to "organize the working class" must now respect the
autonomy and stimulate the growth of organizations of the excluded,
like the MST (Landless Workers' Movement).
If it does not want to repeat the example of the old leftist parties in
Europe, associated with social democracy, the PT cannot deny its
origins or forget what it has said and written. It has no other reason
for being than its commitment to those who started and supported it:
the poor.
For them, who in Brazil are a multitude, there will only be a future
beyond premature death if the goods of the earth and the fruits of
human labor are shared. Martha Suplicy (the winning mayoral candidate
in Sao Paulo) did well to reaffirm modern socialism in her victory
speech. Without this point of orientation the PT will lose its
direction and perspective.
The PT's chances of becoming a government alternative in 2002 depend on
its programmatic and ideological cohesion, based in ethical coherence.
Brazil deserves to lose its title of world champion in social
inequality.
https://www.alainet.org/es/node/105032?language=en
Del mismo autor
- Homenaje a Paulo Freire en el centenario de su nacimiento 14/09/2021
- Homenagem a Paulo Freire em seu centenário de nascimento 08/09/2021
- FSM: de espaço aberto a espaço de acção 04/08/2020
- WSF: from an open space to a space for action 04/08/2020
- FSM : d'un espace ouvert à un espace d'action 04/08/2020
- FSM: de espacio abierto a espacio de acción 04/08/2020
- Ética em tempos de pandemia 27/07/2020
- Carta a amigos y amigas del exterior 20/07/2020
- Carta aos amigos e amigas do exterior 20/07/2020
- Direito à alimentação saudável 09/07/2020